A star wars executorclass super star destroyer, one of the largest ships. Do you really think the enterprise could take on the likes of the death star, a super star destroyer, or even a fleet of tie fighters. The fall of the empire data and solo lead a strike force into the death star, while luke battles vader and the emperor. Your average acclamator class troop carrier the star destroyer like ships in episode 2 had 200 gigaton firepower per shot. The warhead was then smuggled onto the star destroyer invincible, destroying it from the inside. William shatner disses star wars, says star trek is better. Picard whips past darth vaders ship doing warp 7, popping off photon torpedos at each pass. Exclusive to walmart for now, this rc star destroyer drone is just under 12 in width at its widest. For the most part, its entirely unsatisfying to compare enterprise vs. Star destroyer for precisely the reasons you state.
Can a nuclear bomb destroy a star destroyer in one hit. If the enterprise is forced to exit warp, it gets destroyed pretty quickly. S enterprise constitution class refit was beautiful with its new lines and look, and it was great to see the crew reunited, but the film fell flat. It is tightly written, fastpaced, visually excellent, and generally overcomes the fear of commitment to the story that has caused a few of the trek films to fall flat. In that case, when the enterprise backs up at warp 1. The ones in the movie fire bolts of energy, like in star wars. Ending up the victoryclass star destroyer did not make it to the films and for a long time featured only in star wars legends see below. The very tech bases are incompatible and so it makes as much sense as saying would a spitfire win vs. A more valid matchup would be a single man unshielded tiefighter vs the enterprise d. Patrol the skies and crash dramatically with this star wars star destroyer drone. Can the enterprise the one picard commands beat an imperial star destroyer. But in the spirit of the new star trek, this ship is as big as needed. The film was heavily, heavily chopped down, though.
It had a powerful super laser which could destroy any capital ship, and put a crack in a planets crust. Kirk and his team are dropped from the enterprise orbiting above vulcan, and. They have frigates, cruisers, corvettes blockade runners and interdictor class destroyers at all flanks. Cool collections of star destroyer wallpaper hd for desktop, laptop and mobiles. I do not own star trek or star wars, or any part therof. Meanwhile, the executor disables the enterprise defenses and boarding parties swarm aboard the federation ship. A footnote in john grubers analysis of blackberry vs. The falcons tactic for a star destroyer was to hide and run. Larger vessels, such as the super star destroyer, dwarf even these giants. The conversation a b5 star trek crossover star destroyer. The way youve got this set up, the enterprise could stomp a single star destroyer, or a whole fleet of them, which is just dead wrong, and even take on the death star.
All the imperial star destroyers offensive weaponry has been squished somehow on to the enterprise and vice versa. What ever pd turrets fighters or shielding they once had still remains. Forcing them to sitdown and trade shots when their speed and maneuverability are their biggest gains doesnt seem fair. Vader would have to get in range in order to use his force powers.
May 28, 2004 star wars vs star trek in five minutes. After all, the civilization that built the star destroyer built a planet destroying super ship in a reasonably short time frame, which by your logic means that the star destroyer must, by definition, be super badass as well. Buffalo mayor cracks tom brady joke during covid19 press conference. The executor could take on the entire federation fleet without losing shields, or really taking any damage at all. As such a popular driver, the destroyer comes available in all the major plastics. Enterprise to challenge your friends and enemies to fight your foodeating battle monkey, just paste the following html into a web page or email. While some of you may have been to see the new star wars movie, you might be sad that everything happened a long time ago in a galaxy far away. The space strategy game galactic civilizations iii now has steam workshop support, and that means its time to settle an old score. It seems like the death star would be at least 100x bigger than the borg cube. But its weapons are far too light to deal significant damage to the star destroyer. This probably isnt canon but i think its the best we can get. The engineering and transporter room sets of the uss enterprised were. Enterprise wins by showing that discretion is the better part of valour. Download for free on all your devices computer, smartphone, or tablet.
However, the star destroyer is going to be licking some wounds. The destroyer is overstable, but has a degree of turn to help provide incredible glide and distance. Can anyone here draw what a jj abrams enterprised might look like well i was planning on making a joke ship, but i actually kinda like this. If the enterprisee from star trek battled an imperial. Feb 19, 2011 a star destroyer could chew up any incarnation of the uss enterprise and spit it out considering the fact that a star destroyer is a lot more heavily armed than most incarnations of the uss enterprise,although the enterprise e may be able to give a star destroyer a run for its money. The way i see it the only way the falcon could win is by twisting the definition of winning a space battle with the enterprise. The print itself isnt even screenprinted, its that cheap heatbonded vinyl decal stuff they use to make kids. The enterprise transporters would not be able to go through the death star s sheiding. Enterprise constitution class star trek 1966 final refit before. Twentythird century warfare isnt all its cracked up to be. This leaves it unclear whether a nuclear bomb would destroy a star destroyer it were detonated outside of its hull, or what effect the ships shields would have.
Remember in jedi how the death star destroyed a whole rebel ships with the death ray in one shot. Also even if the star trek ship does what it does, the lasers from the batteries travel at light speed, energy weapons fire invisible energy beams at lightspeed. The enterprise vs, the deathstar battles comic vine. The klingon sniper rifle was broken into sections, with parts modeled from real weapons. In the rogue one traileras well as the actual film itselfwe see a star destroyer hovering directly over a city on the planets surface how is it possible. Who would win, the enterprise e or a super star destroyer. There exists only a handful of threats which can seriously challenged even one of these ships.
Intermediate players will get more distance on forehand throws with the destroyer than just about any other disc. We all know st is far superior to sw, anyone who claims the contrary, is delusional. Setting aside the old lines about lasers and navigational shields. This is my interpretation of what a sovergin class starship against a superstar destroyer will be like. So if the enterprise stays at warp speeds it can pretty much attack the star destroyer with impunity. I thought that all capital ships were built in space, because they were too heavy to lift from the planets gravitation after completion. Enterprise ncc1701e sovereignclass vs executorsuper. Here you can see it compared against the battlestar galactica, the good old enterprise. Custom lego star destroyer is so huge it has a threelevel. Generation tech has done a few fun videos estimating the costs of items in the star wars universe.
This is a wonderfully enjoyable star trek film, reminiscent of wrath of khan with several shades of the undiscovered country. See more ideas about star trek, trek and star trek 1. The onscreen, g canon evidence demonstrates that a star destroyer can circumnavigate an earthsized planet in under a minute. The enterprise is a lot more maneuverable that a star destroyer. The second season is then setup with the appearance of the uss enterprise. Whats the most devastating attack a star trek or star wars ship is stated to be able to undertake. Youre average imperialclass star destoyer is 1,600 metres long, nearly twice the size of the enterprise e and more than 3 times that speculated for the one fighting here. The on screen, gcanon evidence demonstrates that even x wings can circumnavigate gas giants within minutes. Here you can see it compared against the battlestar galactica, the good old enterprise, the blockade. Also im seeing the enterprise d as the more resourceful one. The uss enterprise c under the command of captain garrett was sent into the future guaranteeing a war with the klingon empire.
Star destroyer versus enterprise has been the iconic nerd battle since we looked at the enterprise s wonderful mission to find new life beyond the stars and asked, yeah, but how good are you at. Patrol the skies and crash dramatically with this star wars. He even says the new star trek movie by jj abrams has better special effects than star wars. In this tiny meeples, big talk we consider ways that star wars. The imperialclass star destroyer is a design that is intended to inspire fear, and it succeeds admirably at that. Nov 23, 2011 i do not own star trek or star wars, or any part therof. Star destroyer vs enterprise with the ridicuzillions of stars in the universe youd think there would be enough to both trek to and war over, but no. Uss enterprise ncc 1701j vs a star destroyer spacebattles. Darius trent months after the battle of the ivor system, its up the the crew of the arizona to stop the imperial invasion while starfleet command is. Ssds dont go off into space by themselves or any star destroyer, unlike the enterprise. Is it possible for humanity to build a star destroyer like we see in the star wars films. They deploy fighter and bomber wings by the hundreds, and act like amphibious assault ships with atats, storm troopers, etc. Doomhandles isd tyrant is so massive, he was able to fit a hangar. Enterprise d vs super star destroyer anandtech forums.
Star wars vs star trek in five minutes star destroyer. The super star destroyer also has deflector shields, boarding parties, tie fighters, tie bombers. Its presence in a system mark matters of extreme imperial import. Ending up the victoryclass star destroyer did not make it to the films and for a long time featured only in star.
Jul 21, 2015 the way i see it the only way the falcon could win is by twisting the definition of winning a space battle with the enterprise. As a big star wars fan, i felt the book could have been reduced to a single page, with a big yes. Well, in the sake of universal peace among two very disparate yet similar geek tribes or. This was the first speed 12 driver and is one of the primary discs used by many professional disc golfers. Though, as is typical of the empire, not even the star destroyer was enough to sate the imperial hunger for displays of power. Warp drive also allows speeds greater than the speed of light, but not to the extent of hyperspace. The enterprise can use its weapons while traveling ftl, the star destroyer cant. Oct 28, 2012 enterprise ncc1701e sovereign class vs executorsuper star destroyer. If youve ever done research on star wars vs star trek. Need i remind you, in legends, a star destroyer on its own could destroy the surface of an entire inhabited planet in a day.
Its faster because the pilots in the star wars series discovered an alternate dimension that allows travel at several times the speed of light. Enterprise was an exploration ship with only a transport bay. Enterprise vs star destroyer read description youtube. Enterprise to challenge your friends and enemies to fight your foodeating battle monkey, just paste the following html into a. Which would win, the enterprise or a star destoyer. All of the thin lines on the enterprise image are cracked. Jul 10, 2015 the space strategy game galactic civilizations iii now has steam workshop support, and that means its time to settle an old score. Discussion forums normal display ssl encrypted low bandwidth.
Also, since you pointed out that the ed can fire weapons while moving ftl, its no contest. Much but not all of the content comes from the history of the stardestroyer. Enterprise vs imperial star destroyer yet another twist. The vindicator was an imperialclass star destroyer that served in the imperial navy during the galactic civil war. Star trek parodies and pop culture references memory alpha. Do we have the resources, technology and perhaps more importantly the will to do it. Eclipse dreadnought vs 3 executor super star destroyers star. If the enterprisee from star trek battled an imperial star. How could a star destroyer hover over a city in rogue one. Can anyone here draw what a jj abrams enterprised might look. Star wars map, star destroyer ect download minecraft map. The uss enterprisec under the command of captain garrett was sent into the future guaranteeing a war with the klingon empire. The super star destroyer turbolasers alone would obliterate the enterprise before it even got a shot off, never needing the supporting contingent of tie spacecraft.
The expanded universe of star wars books contradict themselves on every level. The first season of the american television series star trek. Imperial star destroyer vs the enterprise d battles. The comparison with the official 2014 star destroyer in the foreground shows how awesome and big this custom ship really is. For less experienced players, the destroyer excels for forehand throws. The visible bolt is a glowing pulse that travels along the beam at less than lightspeed.
Weve gathered more than 3 million images uploaded by our users and sorted them by the most popular ones. Sep 21, 20 download star destroyer a lightweight and portable application that helps users decrypt the passwords hidden behind asterisks quickly and with minimum effort. In this article, he goes on to say that george lucas borrowed everything from star trek. Episode 1 reactions episode 2 reactions episode 3 reactions new sti reactions nemesis synopsis. Star wars this is a star wars inspierd map with lot of builds. One shot and theres a hole in the water where the enterprise is supposed to be. The part that was not known was that the proforces kept the wake opened long enough for the enterprise to follow the borg. During the attack on the death star, the ascendance launched several wings of tie fighters and interceptors, which tore through two squadrons of rebel fighters attempting to break through imperial defenses. Over the years, star treks position as a cultural icon has resulted in many parodies. As the torrent of water dried up for the first time in thousands of years, it revealed a horrific sight. Because the starship enterprise battling an imperial star destroyer. During the attack on the death star, the vindicator was the first to succumb to bombing attacks by rebel fighters, which crippled the capital ships engines and bridge.
Ok, so you dont want to bother reading through this whole site, right. Another perspective a footnote in john grubers analysis of blackberry vs. Map includes star destroyer rebel blockade runner x wing tie fighter tie advanced sandcrawler rebel hangar at at at st lukes home lukes landspeeder. The star destroyer cant see its attacker in warp, even if the enterprise drops out of warp for five seconds two light seconds behind the destroyer it takes time for the empire sensors that move at the speed of light to hit the enterprise and reflect back to the destroyer, lock and swivel the turbo lasers on the target, then two seconds for the beams to reach the spot the enterprise used to be. How big is the new enterprise compared to galactica. A new hope would have been different if obiwan kenobi and luke skywalker had hired the starbug red dwarf crew to get them to alderaan instead of hiring han solo and chewbacca in the millennium falcon. The victoryclass was developed from a prototype star destroyer model created by colin cantwell for a new hope, with the final design being used for the basis of the imperialclass. While you can use the 250 ships that launched with the game to. I am a star wars fan, and a star trek fan too, but i would like to point out well youll see. A star destroyer could chew up any incarnation of the uss enterprise and spit it out considering the fact that a star destroyer is a lot more heavily armed than most incarnations of the uss enterprise,although the enterprise e may be able to give a star destroyer a run for its money. Sep 18, 2016 the ascendance was an imperialclass star destroyer that served in the imperial navy during the galactic civil war.
I have done my own research and have found the following sites to be useful when determining who would win a u. By its very nature, this wiki is likely to reveal important plot points in the movies, shows. This is the imperial wiki, the wiki, which deals with star wars vs star trek, discussing the technology and politics of both sides as well as the relevant sciences. Aug 22, 2011 besides, you could make the same argument for the star destroyer.
837 118 588 353 1472 844 33 1530 909 650 835 455 346 294 683 1021 1374 127 93 117 1452 92 644 1456 450 287 1565 1013 1092 873 1052 530 84 789 1227 672 239 819 399 760 1431 138 293 103